| YOUR SERVER DOWN? READ THE BUSYGAMER.COM ARCHIVES. © 2007-2008 BusyGamer Inc | For more info email admin@busygamer.com | All rights reserved |
| SEPTEMBER 2, 2008 |
| 08.29.08 Penny Arcade Coverage : Blog Week 08.27.08 Cher as Catwoman? / Warhammer goes Gold 08.26.08 Cordless computers / No more Scrabulous |
Guitar Zero Vs. Guitar Hero
By Crutchboy
So we're back from Penny Arcade Seattle, back to the grind and hot Texas
weather. I saw some great things at PAX and you too will see them
coming up in the next week or two here on the site...meanwhile...
I made some interesting observations at the con over the weekend, and it
may ruffle some feathers here and there but honestly it shouldn't - it is as I
said, an observation, (plus I have been known to be a jerk sometimes).
So we're back from Penny Arcade Seattle, back to the grind and hot Texas
weather. I saw some great things at PAX and you too will see them
coming up in the next week or two here on the site...meanwhile...
I made some interesting observations at the con over the weekend, and it
may ruffle some feathers here and there but honestly it shouldn't - it is as I
said, an observation, (plus I have been known to be a jerk sometimes).
I am quite aware that I write and work for Busy Gamer, and this is a gaming website and all,
but I feel quite feebleminded at the "gaming rock banders" out there. Not that it isn't a great
game, Guitar Hero and Rock Band are fantastic. Marketing and popularity are amazing, I'm
guessing they will only get better. What I don't understand is the fascination to take the reality
of it being a "game", to trying to make it "more than a game".
I watched the Rock Band stage at PAX, the players lined up, prepping for that GnR tune,
tightening their headbands and wiping their brows waiting for the ready set go, they pound
out the song, crowd is singing along, applause is strong, the guys are high fiving at their
score as they step of the stage, like a performance from Woodlands Pavilion.
Ok, yeah they feel great. I see it. It is real. Why am I so bugged? It's because I am an
entertainer myself for about 22 years (yeah I'm old who cares). It is an overwhelming feeling
for those kids to get a response like that. So why not pick up a real guitar and do the same
thing and really move some people?
Is it the skill set? Nope. I've played Guitar Hero, they are similar. And very learnable. The
amount of time it takes to excel at it, can at the very least sit on a miniature comparable level. I
like the feeling in front of fans. And I think that these kids and adults on stage with a virtual
complete band would love it. My bands have shared shows with great acts like The Misfits
and Bayside, and to perform for a crowd and see kids and adults sing back at you YOUR
songs, not Velvet Revolvers, is going to lay waste to any red red green blue combo move that
you'll ever turn out.
Yeah I know, it's a game. It's altered the standards for gaming, and will continue to do so for
years to come. Kids and adults, I'm not saying to stop playing Guitar Hero or Rock Band, I'm
saying play them, AND after you score 98% on Nights in White Satin on expert level, go
borrow your old and crusty neighbors Les Paul knock off and give it a try if you haven't already.
Find an old drum kit from the garage sale down the block, and get the crazy kid Louie with the
lazy eye to try screaming some words he scribbled on his math book while he sat stargazed
at sweet sally from homeroom class.
You get it. I know you do. Or you should, I hope. There is a lot more than screen shotting your
1,034 note streak. Try "thinking out of your xbox" sometime, it's quite a face melter. [comment]
-Crutchboy Out aka Scott Free / Worm Suicide / Madagain Saints
but I feel quite feebleminded at the "gaming rock banders" out there. Not that it isn't a great
game, Guitar Hero and Rock Band are fantastic. Marketing and popularity are amazing, I'm
guessing they will only get better. What I don't understand is the fascination to take the reality
of it being a "game", to trying to make it "more than a game".
I watched the Rock Band stage at PAX, the players lined up, prepping for that GnR tune,
tightening their headbands and wiping their brows waiting for the ready set go, they pound
out the song, crowd is singing along, applause is strong, the guys are high fiving at their
score as they step of the stage, like a performance from Woodlands Pavilion.
Ok, yeah they feel great. I see it. It is real. Why am I so bugged? It's because I am an
entertainer myself for about 22 years (yeah I'm old who cares). It is an overwhelming feeling
for those kids to get a response like that. So why not pick up a real guitar and do the same
thing and really move some people?
Is it the skill set? Nope. I've played Guitar Hero, they are similar. And very learnable. The
amount of time it takes to excel at it, can at the very least sit on a miniature comparable level. I
like the feeling in front of fans. And I think that these kids and adults on stage with a virtual
complete band would love it. My bands have shared shows with great acts like The Misfits
and Bayside, and to perform for a crowd and see kids and adults sing back at you YOUR
songs, not Velvet Revolvers, is going to lay waste to any red red green blue combo move that
you'll ever turn out.
Yeah I know, it's a game. It's altered the standards for gaming, and will continue to do so for
years to come. Kids and adults, I'm not saying to stop playing Guitar Hero or Rock Band, I'm
saying play them, AND after you score 98% on Nights in White Satin on expert level, go
borrow your old and crusty neighbors Les Paul knock off and give it a try if you haven't already.
Find an old drum kit from the garage sale down the block, and get the crazy kid Louie with the
lazy eye to try screaming some words he scribbled on his math book while he sat stargazed
at sweet sally from homeroom class.
You get it. I know you do. Or you should, I hope. There is a lot more than screen shotting your
1,034 note streak. Try "thinking out of your xbox" sometime, it's quite a face melter. [comment]
-Crutchboy Out aka Scott Free / Worm Suicide / Madagain Saints